Court sides with West Coast natives to sell fish

The B.C. Court of Appeal has unanimously affirmed the right of five Nuu-chah-nulth First Nations to harvest and sell any species of fish in their territories with the exception of geoduck clams.

  • May. 24, 2011 9:00 a.m.

The B.C. Court of Appeal has unanimously affirmed the right of five Nuu-chah-nulth First Nations to harvest and sell any species of fish in their territories with the exception of geoduck clams.

The Court of Appeal recently upheld a November 2009 decision of the B.C. Supreme Court that recognized the Nuu-chah-nulth as having these rights, based on the central importance of fishing and trading fish throughout their history.

After reviewing the various sources of evidence, the three Court of Appeal Justices unanimously concluded that “all tend to be supportive of the judge’s finding that there was significant intertribal trade in early times at and before contact in fisheries products on the coast and across Vancouver Island by the ancestors of the respondents.”

The court divided on the precise definition of the right to sell fish. The majority affirmed the trial judge’s characterization that the Nuu-chah-nulth have a right to sell fish into the commercial marketplace, with the precise scale to be negotiated with Canada. The dissenting justice found that the right should be characterized as being for a “moderate livelihood” only.

The court also agreed with the trial judge that Canada’s management of the fisheries has not respected Nuu-chah-nulth’s aboriginal rights; the court provided the parties one year to design a fishery that recognizes these rights.

The federal government appealed the original decision, disputing the trial judge’s findings that enough evidence exists to support the claim that Nuu-chah-nulth Nations have an aboriginal right to fish and sell fish commercially. Canada also argued that the trial judge did not accurately apply the test previously set out by the Supreme Court of Canada for determining aboriginal rights.

The Court of Appeal did not allow the government’s appeal, finding instead that there was ample evidence to support the trial judge’s findings, and that she did accurately apply the Supreme Court test.

“It was neither possible nor desirable for the trial judge to articulate the precise content of the Aboriginal rights at issue at the outset of her analysis. The respondents were entitled to plead their claim broadly. The judge properly placed primary focus on evidence about the pre-contact practice,” wrote Justice Hall for the Court of Appeal decision.

The court did agree with one part of Canada’s argument by not extending the aboriginal right to the modern geoduck fishery.

The case, which spanned much of the last decade, began in 2003 when Nuu-chah-nulth Nations filed a summons against Canada and B.C. The claims were based on aboriginal rights to harvest and sell sea resources, aboriginal title to fishing territories and fishing sites.

and the unique obligations of the Crown arising through the reserve-creation process.

After Confederation, Canada encouraged the Nuu-chah-nulth to remain fishing people by allocating small fishing stations as reserves while denying the larger land claims of the Nations. Over the next hundred years, Canada decreased and excluded Nuu-chah-nulth participation in the West Coast fishery through government regulation.

“Once again the courts have recognized that fishing has always been integral to our economy and our culture. This latest ruling acknowledges our aboriginal right to share in the resources provided by the sea,” said NTC President Cliff Atleo Sr.

The decision comes after months of difficult negotiations between the Nations and the Department of Fisheries and Oceans Canada. Despite direction from the trial Judge to negotiate the details of a rights-based fishery, Canada has been reluctant to engage in a meaningful way.

“We look forward to implementing the Court’s decision in cooperation with DFO,” said Atleo. “We have always understood there will continue to be a shared fisheries regime on the West Coast of Vancouver Island, and look forward to creating a fishery that will benefit all west coast communities,” he said.

 

Just Posted

Man suffering heart attack not allowed to board Quadra Island ferry

Quadra Island man recovering after being airlifted to hospital in Victoria

Oyster River salmon numbers bouyant, Quinsam/Campbell data not so

By Neil Cameron Special to the Mirror In a tale of two… Continue reading

Boy with terminal disease gets his wish – a trip to Disneyland – but family still looking for support

Kaleb Francis, 4, was diagnosed last month with X-linked myotubular myopathy

Local artisan calls new Marine Harvest brand ‘inappropriate,’ too close to his Indigenous name

Salmon farming company prepares for name change amid objections from Mowisaht Designs

The Nutcracker comes alive in two Campbell River performances

River-Port Danceworks show featured professional dancers Danielle Gould and Giovanni Giordano

Retired B.C. teacher a YouTube Sudoku sensation

A retired Kelowna teacher has amassed quite the following online by teaching the art of solving a Sudoku puzzle.

Girl, 6, lured from elementary school, sexually assaulted: Vancouver police

Police are seeking dashcam footage from nearby Sexsmith Elementary School in South Vancouver

B.C. Liberals call for outside audit of Speaker’s office

Auditor General implicated in Darryl Plecas accusations of impropriety

Three victims of ex-ski coach Bertrand Charest suing Alpine Canada

The victims are also seeking $150,000 each in punitive damages

Trudeau names four new senators, filling every seat in the Senate

Trudeau has appointed 49 senators since becoming prime minister and will have the chance to appoint more in 2019

B.C. member of parliament takes feds to task on opioid crisis

‘Too many families are tragically losing parents, siblings and children to the opioid crisis.’

Judge gives Michael Cohen 3 years in prison

Judge William H. Pauley III said Cohen deserved a harsh punishment for crimes including tax evasion

Humboldt Broncos, cannabis, Fortnite: Here are Canadians’ top Google searches for 2018

When celebrities died or Canada Post went on strike, Canada turned to Google

Most Read